11 May 2011

Goering's dealers and collectors in Italy

Any provenance work pertaining to works and objects of art entering or leaving Italy during and after the Nazi era must cast a pall of suspicion on the following individuals who traded occasionally or frequently with Hermann Goering through two of his principal agents, Walther Hofer and Josef Angerer. Joseph Angerer, who swept through French Jewish collections in Paris during the summer of 1940 on Goering’s account, also acquired works in Rome while he stayed at the Hotel Excelsior there. Some items—tapestries mostly—were purchased from American or British owners living in Rome at the time. Angerer was also well acquainted in Florence with Contini and Bellini, and befriended Grassi there. He knew the city of Milan like the back of his hand.

The bulk of this information stems from detailed postwar interrogations and debriefings of Walther Hofer.

Florence:
  • Luigi Bellini
  • Conte Contini--Sometimes, Contini dealt with Goering through Reber, one of Hofer’s oldest friends who lived in Switzerland, using the Rome-based shipping company, Martelli and Rosoni.
  • Giulio Grassi
  • Commandantore Ventura
  • Dr. Victor Wallerstein
Genoa:
  • Eldebaudo Bossi--Bossi also dealt with Jacques Dubourg, a Paris dealer who was very busy during the Vichy years. Dubourg served as a go-between for Hofer for sales to Goering.
Milan:
  • Ferruccia Asta
Rome:
  • Alfredo Barsauli
  • Ugo Fandola
  • Dr. Alessandro Morandotti
  • Galleria Sangiorgi
  • Galleria Simonetti
  • Graf Alessandro Tatistscheff
  • Contessa Lina Traine
  • Fr. Irene von Benda
  • Fraulein Staeger
  • Dr. Ettore Sestieri, art historian, director of Galleria Barberini.
  • Brasini
Venice:
  • Albert Maier

10 May 2011

More on restitution in postwar Italy

by Marc Masurovsky

Reviewed and updated on 4 November 2025

Renewed attention is being given to the scope and breadth of objects of art plundered by the Nazis and their allies which entered the art market in Italy during the fateful years of the Third Reich and beyond. An upcoming seminar to be held in Milan on 23 June 2011 is being co-sponsored by the global auction house, Christie’s, and the Art Law Commission of the Union Internationale des Avocats (UIA). It will bring together international specialists and lawyers adept at working on art restitution cases including the New York law firm of Herrick, Feinstein, and the Commission on Art Recovery (CAR).

The goal is to paint a broad picture of the state of affairs in postwar Italy regarding the restitution of Holocaust-era looted art, what can be done about improving the climate of restitution in a country that has long prided itself for having taken the lead in the search for and recovery of works of art forcibly removed from its territory.

And therein lies the rub…

Successive Italian governments—and there have been a great many of them!—have focused their attention almost exclusively on the plunder initiated by Nazi Germany when it sent its troops deep into Italy after the removal of Mussolini in 1943. Hence, the official window of plunder in Italy has always been considered to be a ‘foreign’ affair, the responsibility for which must be laid at Germany’s feet between 1943 and 1945. Moreover, in a cynical move to prevent plundered art from leaving the country, the Italian government appears to be commingling all plundered art as 'cultural property.' Should that be the case, this signals an ominous turn against the possibility of recovering Holocaust-era cultural goods found in Italy.

Convenient… 

In 1922, Benito Mussolini led a March on Rome which heralded the rise to power of Fascism, an authoritarian, one-party system. It remained firmly entrenched in the Italian boot for 21 years until German troops invaded their Fascist ally and forced Mussolini out of power. 

In 1938, the Fascist government edicts the so-called “Manifesto of Race” which defines who is a Jew, aping the Nazi government and foreshadowing Vichy’s contribution to anti-Semitic legislations by two years. From that time on, Jews are no longer safe in Italy, nor is their property. 

After the Germain invasion of summer 1943, Mussolini became the nominal head of the Salo Republic, governed by hard-core dye-in-the-wool Fascist unrepentants who spent most of their time plundering and fighting the Partisans, Meanwhile, the Nazi occupiers went to work deporting thousands of Jews from Italy to concentration and extermination camps in Eastern Europe.
Republic of Salo, 1943-1945

During that time frame, the Fascist Party ran amok against its opponents, harassing them, arresting them, imprisoning them, and when it deemed fit, murdering them “while trying to escape.” Many others were forced into exile or confined to the ‘villeggiatura’, a semblance of house arrest in the deep rural south of Italy for anti-Fascist intellectuals. All the while, opponents’ property was seized, stolen, and reincorporated into the economy of Fascist Italy, if it didn’t end up in the homes of prominent Fascist dignitaries.

Hence, the questions that should be asked at this seminar bear especially on the 21 years of Fascist rule, including 5 years of Fascist Italian anti-Jewish persecutions and expropriations.

The art market

Italy remained an open market, regardless of Fascist strictures, importing and exporting and doing business with countries around the globe. The Italian art world continued to maintain good relations with its neighbors, buying, selling, and trading. As it turns out, Italy was a convenient place for Nazi dealers and museum officials to meet up with their counterparts in Italy and from other countries.

During the height of the anti-Jewish persecutions in German-occupied Europe, Italian art dealers were more than happy to accept as payment, in lieu of cash, works of art which Nazi officials did not deem suitable for their collections, especially modernists. Where did those works go?

As importantly, Northern Italy was a hotbed of smuggling and contraband of all manners of commodities, including art, during the period of German occupation, activities often supervised by Nazi intelligence operatives, the most notorious being Freddy Schwend, based in Merano.

And one should not forget the Vatican, which curried favor to all sorts of authoritarian, racialist regimes in the 1930s and 1940s, enabling safe passage in the late 1940s and 1950s for untold numbers of Axis collaborators and plunderers on their journeys across the Mediterranean Sea and into the Americas, under the pretext that they had solid anti-Communist credentials.

On a final note, Italy came up during the May 6-7, 2011, World War II Provenance Research Seminar in Washington, DC, within the framework of an ambitious project overseen by the National Gallery of Art to fully document the acquisitions made by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation.  The Count Contini-Bonacossi had been Mr. Kress' 'art advisor'.  Contini-Bonacossi's credentials placed him as a major Italian art dealer with privileged ties to Hitler and Goering's minions as well as with their intermediaries operating in German-occupied France, Belgium, and Holland.  Something to keep in mind...

Sources:


Photo of Benito Mussolini courtesy of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benito_Mussolini




09 May 2011

On a more positive note…

Regardless of where the fracture lines are drawn in the art world over the questions of provenance, due diligence and restitution, the May 6-7, 2011, seminar in Washington, DC, did highlight the wealth of information that now exists at one’s fingertips.

Much was jokingly said about being able to conduct hours of research from the comfort of one’s bed. As silly as that might sound, it’s not far from the truth, up to a point.

To wit:

The International Research Portal hailed as a major breakthrough in research on art looting is not a major breakthrough, but it is a significant step forward towards making such resources more available to individuals and institutions far and wide in search of pertinent documentation. In large part, the Portal itself provides access to finding aids and, to a far lesser extent, scanned versions of archival documents, and then it’s mostly pay-for-access.

However, the better news lies in the increasing power of art-historical databases in a variety of museums and research institutes both in the United States and Europe, and as far as the Ukraine. The combined strength of those databases covers close to half-a-million objects which is nothing to sneeze at.

Also, a number of institutions such as the Frick Art Reference Library and the Archives of American Art have made major strides in focusing their efforts on access to collections of private dealers, art historians, and artists of direct relevance to research focused on the 1930s to the 1950s. If you add to those the on-line art historical resources available in the Netherlands, Germany, Italy, Austria, a movement is afoot towards more comprehensive research possibilities.

And yet, the skeptic rears his ugly head and wonders how to make sense out of all these resources.

One way of doing so is to provide the kind of research assistance to anyone seeking it and which has been sorely lacking to date as well as methodological pointers on how to approach complex forensic research on looted art and, more specifically, how to contextualize the raw data so as to make sense out of them.

For that and many other reasons, and yes! you heard it here, this blog will devote much of its energy to illustrating how to conduct historical/forensic research into the history of objects that might have been looted during the fateful Nazi/Fascist years. It might not happen every day, but we will do our very best to address this issue at least once a week.

Pearls of wisdom from the May 6-7, 2011 Provenance Research Seminar

“You can’t restitute if you don’t have good research,” Kaywin Feldman, AAMD

Interesting comment in view of the fact that, traditionally, American museums are loath to restitute regardless of how thorough and meticulous the historical research is on objects being claimed by victims.

“Who knew what when?.... There is no statute of limitations on genocide.” Jim Leach, National Endowment for the Humanities.

A marvelous truism by former Congressman Jim Leach, who was the most outspoken advocate of a public dialogue on Holocaust-era looted assets in Congress during the Clinton years. The principle that genocide trumps statutory limits is an ethical principle that has not permeated national courts either in the Americas or in Europe.

“Provenance research is restitution research,” Lynn Nicholas, author, The Rape of Europa

Here, I beg to differ with Lynne Nicholas. Restitution is a possible outcome of provenance research but it is not the incentive underlying it. Provenance research, above all, is about due diligence, transparency, and intellectual honesty.

“Why do we need footnote.com? Why not open source access to historical documents?”, Uwe Hartmann, Bureau for Provenance Investigation and Research, Berlin

Uwe Hartmann raised a fundamental point about the proprietary and for-profit nature of current research tools in the digital world that are being made available to the general and specialized publics. Indeed, the National Archives in the United States had entered into a contract with a private company that produces digital versions of archival records, www.footnote.com. Unfortunately, the idea of paying to have access to an un-indexed, un-catalogued, un-organized document that could just easily be retrieved from an archive without having to pay off is somewhat injurious, unless, of course, you have no plans on coming to College Park, MD, or Washington, DC, for that matter. The same holds true for the National Archives of the United Kingdom which charge for downloads of archival documents.

The idea of open source is one that is extremely popular in the computer programming world but one which has not entered into the habits of researchers and historians who are, by nature, proprietary about their work for obvious professional reasons guided by publishing and career-enhancing considerations.  Historical archives starved for cash are resorting to commercial tactics to replenish their coffers. By doing so, they penalize their audience and make it more difficult and penurious to conduct historical research.

Nevertheless, in an ideal world, digital historical information should be publicly-available much as the database of art objects at the Jeu de Paume tries to do by unleashing on-line as a public service all that there is to know, as of now, on art thefts in German-occupied France.