09 May 2011

Lessons of the May 6-7, 2011, World War II Provenance Research Seminar

An event such as this one does not happen very often, especially not in Washington, DC.

Co-sponsored by the National Archives and the two leading museum associations in the United States, partially underwritten by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, this seminar promised to deliver a hefty dose of knowledge and information culled from the provenance research experience of American museums.

Who came?

In attendance were representatives from over 50 American museums, including Hawaii and Puerto Rico, and one museum from Zurich, Switzerland. The two global leaders of the auction market were on hand, Christie’s and Sotheby’s, as well as a handful of American restitution lawyers, representatives of claimants’ organizations, the New York-based Holocaust Claims Processing Office (HCPO), the Holocaust Art Restitution Project (HARP) and the Conference on Jewish Material Claims against Germany (Claims Conference).

The director of the archives at the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs decided to show the flag for France, one can only presume that it was a last-minute decision but a good one at that. Only one claimant was in attendance: the heirs of Paul Rosenberg whose archive is being offered for research via the Museum of Modern Art in New York. A number of independent researchers were in the room, from Canada, France, the United States, Austria, and the United Kingdom. The US Department of State sent a delegation as well, perforce.

However, no scholars of the Second World War and the Nazi era were invited, except for yours truly, a strange feeling since the Holocaust is, well, a historical event that engulfed tens of millions of individuals on a continental scale for 12 long and painful years.

What’s new?

The field of provenance research has not evolved in substance, only in numbers. The training programs are seriously flawed since they are not equipped to provide contextual and forensic content to those who are not familiar with this line of research.

The emphasis of the conference has been heavily weighted, almost untenably so, towards resources in Germany and Holland. Not a bad thing in and of itself, in fact, those resources are extraordinary and growing by leaps and bounds, but they are solely and exclusively focused on market disruptions within the former Reich and German-occupied Holland. There is no novelty here, simply additional layering of information. And, yet, as was pointed out by several individuals, not many, the thefts of art plagued 19 countries. Should sought objects have entered the Netherlands and Germany, one can only be so lucky, resources are available to garner information about them, assuming, of course, that these objects fit within a specific art-historical mold.

Discrimination through art history

Not to make a big deal about this, but…

The bias of art historians and museum experts remains as pronounced today as it has always been ever since the issue of looted art entered into popular consciousness. From the forlorn days of recovery in the post-1945 world to the present, research remains limited to the great masters of Western culture who have entered the pantheon of US museums. There still is no room for the thousands of artists whose works were the subject of misappropriation but the appreciation of which never extended into the collecting habits of Tier One and Tier Two museums in the United States as well as objects produced by other cultures, three-dimensional objects and decorative pieces. As one curator indicated from the Harvard Museums, provenance research is limited to works in their collections. Ergo…

What is to be done?

Unbeknownst to the organizers of this two-day provenance fiesta, or if they do know, they simply cast it aside, many attendees moped about the crying need for international coordination of research into looted art, including some of our colleagues from Germany. They request federated or unified resources on-line and human in order to strengthen and broaden research talent and resources. Training is sorely lacking as most acknowledge that they are overwhelmed by the level of complexity inherent to conducting research into the whereabouts of works that changed hands illicitly over decades. And yet, there is no recognizable effort by the Museum associations to promote the kind of training that is essential if one is to harness the complexities of art thefts that occurred within a genocidal context over 60 years ago.

What can be the answer to such striking levels of inaction and institutionalized passivity? Independent efforts that lie outside the museum community are our only hope, fueled by organizations, foundations, and perhaps even research institutes in Europe and the Americas whose interest lies in providing utmost transparency in the revelation of the myriad ways in which art works and objects have been mishandled until today. For instance, there is a glimmer of hope in Prague where the European Shoah Legacies Institute (ESLI) is finally coming together and may in fact one day find ways of encouraging and promoting what precisely the US museum community is loath to do—training and contextualized historical research into the wartime and postwar fate of looted objects of art. Also, in Munich, the Central Institute for Art History possesses over 8000 photographs of objects that include many which were forcibly removed from France and Belgium. The Institute appears to be willing to promote such international exchanges of ideas and resources and its invitation is most welcome.

Last but not least…

For once, US museum officials have acknowledged that their attention has been too focused on Old Masters and Impressionists and must extend to three-dimensional objects from Asia. This is good since the Freer Gallery in Washington, DC, appears to be leading the charge, albeit modestly.

A parting shot

The future lies in full transparency of resources and the revamping of thousands of so-called provenances so that they reflect accurately the sinews of ownership that go along with objects that are hundreds of years old or even simply seventy years old. Museums must promote the accurate labeling of those histories so as to inform their public of the extraordinary journeys that those objects have taken in order to reach their walls. Until such time, opacity will reign supreme, intellectual dishonesty will veil the truth behind the histories of those objects and the ensuing lapses in ethical behavior will dominate a field that ought to be celebrating its resources and contributions to world knowledge about art.

04 May 2011

Now open for business: The “International Research Portal” on Nazi-era looting of objects of art

International Research Portal for Records Related to Nazi-Era Cultural Property
Source: NARA
A newfangled “International Research Portal” has been launched to facilitate archival research on Nazi looting of art objects across Europe between 1933 and 1945. An official ceremony is scheduled to take place in Washington, DC, on May 5, 2011. The launch of the portal will be followed by an international conference on provenance research attended for the most part by museum professionals, provenance researchers, art experts.  Except for Lynn Nicholas and Patricia Grimsted who bring to the May 6-7, 2011, Provenance Research Conference, their respective focus on plunder of cultural objects, archives, and books, noted absences are those of pioneers of looted art research like Willi Korte and Konstantin Akinsha who blazed trails in the untangling of complex webs of illicit ownership of art objects in continental Europe.  Such is life...

The creation of this Portal is unprecedented.  It brings together through a common virtual gateway the archival holdings of the Bundesarchiv in Germany, the National Archives in the United States, the National Archives of the United Kingdom, the archives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of France, the Central State Archive of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine (TsDAVO), the State Archives of Belgium, the Munich Central Collecting Point and Linz databases, the Database of Art Objects at the Jeu de Paume, and the victims’ database of the “Memorial de la Shoah” in Paris, France.

Co-sponsors of this international effort include the Claims Conference and the Commission for Looted Art in Europe.

Of course, reality sets in quickly.  If one clicks on the link to the London-based Commission for Looted Art in Europe, the page that pops up offers us a link to the Nazi-Era Cultural Property Project.  Click on Search and one is prompted to enter search terms from which to retrieve documents. I typed “Jeu de Paume” and received 9 hits. I clicked on a prompt to obtain more details about the documents and at the bottom of the new page, I am prompted to place an order for the document in exchange for a fee. Sigh! The cost of doing business, I presume. This is the new age when research is no longer free.

The best part of the Portal  is the access to finding aids from 6 different archives and at least three looted art databases—Jeu de Paume, Munich Central Collecting Point and Linzmuseum—all essential tools for conducting complex research projects on Nazi-era plunder of cultural objects.

Who should get credit for all of this? By its very nature, the “International Research Portal” is the fruit of a lengthy negotiation between archives, governments, and non-profit organizations, in a half-dozen countries. The next step is to make sense of this overwhelming mass of records and to provide coherent, sensible road maps on how best to use them.

Please check out the research portal at http://www.archives.gov/research/holocaust/international-resources/.

03 May 2011

The Jewish question at the Jeu de Paume, 1940-1944

Needless to say, the ostensible function of the Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR) was to remove from all territories under Nazi influence or domination by whatever available means all cultural items, writ large, from owners, custodians, and possessors identified as “Jewish.”

In German-occupied Paris, the Jeu de Paume turned into an unwieldy processing center for all objects plundered by units of the ERR as well as their colleagues in the Gestapo, the so-called Geheime Feld Polizei GFP) or Field Police Units and the Devisenschutzkommandos (DSKs)—technically, those responsible for monitoring the illicit ownership of metals, securities, and jewels in banks and financial institutions.  Some of those objects even came from Brussels.

Official Nazi cultural policy aimed at the elimination of all Jewish influence from Kultur.

Yet, when art historians, experts, and museum officials screened, sorted, catalogued, and indexed those stolen objects before their shipment to the Reich, the Nazi crusade against Jews revealed some serious cracks.

Jozef Israels, Belg. MA-B 35
Source: Bundesarchiv via ERR Project
Although they constitute a very small minority of the stolen objects brought into the Jeu de Paume for “processing,” the ERR staff mulled the fate of 61 works produced by artists identified explicitly as “Jude!”. The verdict: Not a single one of those works was destroyed. Of that group, 8 were set aside to be sold on the Paris art market, 1 was slated for exchange, and the rest, so far as we know, were shipped out to the Reich, of which 10 are known to have been repatriated to France.


The following “Jude!” artists authored those 61 works:

Jules Adler, MA-B 1002
Source: Bundesarchiv via ERR Project
Max Liebermann, Si-ERF 1
Source: Bundesarchiv via ERR Project
Jules Adler, Naoum Aronson, Léon Bakst, Marc Chagall, Jehudo Epstein, Grigory Gluckmann, Leopold Horowitz, Jozef Israels, Max Jacob, Moïse Kisling, Alphonse Lévy, Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer, Max Liebermann, Amédéo Modigliani, Max (Mopp) Oppenheim, Emil Orlik, Jules Pascin, Claude Pissarro, Chaim Soutine, Eugen Spiro, André Strauss, Lesser Ury, Eugène Zak.

For more information, go to www.errproject.org/jeudepaume and search on each individual artist.


An Interactive sneak peek at the schedule for May 6-7, 2011, World War II Provenance Research Seminar in Washington, DC

A New Era of Collaboration and Digitized Resources: 
World War II Provenance Research Seminar
May 6-7, 2011

United States National Archives
700 Pennsylvania Avenue Northwest
Washington, D.C. 20408-0002
(Please use the Special Events Entrance, 
Constitution Avenue between 7th and 9th Streets, NW)

Friday, May 6

9:30 – 10:15 REGISTRATION AND CONTINENTAL BREAKFAST

MORNING SESSION: INTERNATIONAL PORTAL FOR NAZI-ERA CULTURAL PROPERTY RECORDS

10:15 – 11:15 WELCOME

James Hastings, United States National Archives, Washington, DC
Kaywin Feldman, Association of Art Museum Directors

INTRODUCTORY REMARKS

Jim Leach, National Endowment for the Humanities, Washington, DC
Lynn H. Nicholas, Independent Scholar, Washington, DC

11:15 – 12:15 PRESENTATIONS

Rebecca Warlow, United States National Archives
Hans-Dieter Kreikamp, Federal Archives, Berlin
Anne Webber, Commission for Looted Art in Europe, London
Kyrylo Vyslobokov, Archival Information Systems, Kyiv

12:15 – 1:00 DISCUSSION MODERATED BY

Nancy H. Yeide, National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC
Victoria Reed, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

1:00 – 2:00 LUNCH ON YOUR OWN

AFTERNOON SESSION: INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES AND COOPERATIVE PROJECTS FOR NAZI-ERA CULTURAL PROPERTY RECORDS

2:15 – 3:00 PRESENTATIONS

Patricia Kennedy Grimsted, Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute, Cambridge
Marc Masurovsky, Independent Historian, Washington, DC
Wolfgang Schöddert, Ferdinand Möller Archive, Berlinische Galerie, Berlin

3:00 – 3:15 BREAK

3:15 – 4:00 PRESENTATIONS

Andrea Baresel-Brand, Coordination Office for Lost Cultural Assets, Magdeburg
Uwe Hartmann, Bureau for Provenance Investigation and Research, Berlin
Christian Fuhrmeister, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte (Central Institute for Art History), Munich

4:00 – 4:30 DISCUSSION MODERATED BY

Jane Milosch, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC
Christian Fuhrmeister, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte

6:00 – 8:00 RECEPTION: FREER GALLERY OF ART, SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION

Please use the Jefferson Drive entrance, located at 12th Street SW

WELCOME

Richard Kurin, Office of the Under Secretary for History, Art, and Culture, Smithsonian Institution
Julian Raby, Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M. Sackler Gallery, Smithsonian Institution

Saturday, May 7

10:00 – 10:30 CONTINENTAL BREAKFAST

MORNING SESSION: ARCHIVAL RESOURCES FOR PROVENANCE RESEARCH, PART I

10:30 – 10:45 INTRODUCTORY REMARKS

Louisa Wood Ruby, The Frick Art Reference Library, New York

10:45 – 11:30 PRESENTATIONS

Jona Mooren, Nederlandse Museumvereniging (Netherlands Museums Association), Amsterdam, and Rijksbureau voor Kunsthistorische Documentatie (Netherlands Institute for Art History), The Hague
Marisa Bourgoin, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution
Michelle Elligott, Museum of Modern Art Archives, New York

11:30 – 12:15 DISCUSSION MODERATED BY

Laurie Stein, Smithsonian Institution
Sarah Kianovsky, Harvard Art Museums, Cambridge

12:15 – 1:30 LUNCH ON YOUR OWN

AFTERNOON SESSION: ARCHIVAL RESOURCES FOR PROVENANCE RESEARCH, PART II

1:45 – 2:30 PRESENTATIONS

Christian Huemer, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles
Megan Lewis, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Washington, DC
Anneliese Schallmeiner, Commission for Provenance Research, Vienna

2:30 – 2:45 BREAK

2:45 – 3:30 NEW PROJECTS AND RESOURCES

Helen Schretlen, Nederlandse Museumvereniging
Dorota Chudzicka and David Hogge, Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M. Sackler Gallery
Nancy H. Yeide, Kress Collection Provenance Research Project, National Gallery of Art

3:30 – 4:15 DISCUSSION MODERATED BY

Nancy H. Yeide, National Gallery of Art
Laurie Stein, Smithsonian Institution

4:15 – 4:30 CONCLUDING REMARKS

Lynn H. Nicholas, Independent Scholar

The seminar is sponsored by the United States National Archives, the Association of Art Museum Directors, the American Association of Museums and the Smithsonian Institution, with additional support provided by The Samuel H. Kress Foundation and James P. Hayes.